Page 1 of 6

Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Tue May 19, 2009 6:56 pm
by Mev
18650.gif

Host is an EagleTac T100C2, on Hi mode.



18650_aw.jpg

AW 2200mAh, Protected (button-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 01:49, and 01:58 to 50%.
Output then drops linearly before leveling to a gentler concave curve.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.



aw2600.jpg

AW 2600mAh, Protected (flat-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 03:04, and 03:15 to 50%.
Output then drops almost linearly.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.



18650_eagletac.jpg

EagleTac 2400mAh, Protected (button-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 02:43, and 02:54 to 50%.
Output then drops almost linearly.
Over-discharge protection circuit triggers when output reached about 20%.



18650_kaidomain.jpg

Kai Domain 1950mAh, Protected (plain blue label, button-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 01:36, and 02:22 to 50%.
Output then drops in a convex curve.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.



18650_pila.jpg

Pila 2200mAh, Protected (flat-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 02:33, and 02:42 to 50%.
Output then drops almost linearly.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.



trustfire.jpg

TrustFire 2400mAh, Protected (button-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 02:52, and 03:08 to 50%.
Output then drops almost linearly.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.



UltraFire_2600.jpg

UltraFire 2600mAh, Protected (pinklabel, button-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 03:02, and 03:13 to 50%.
Output then drops almost linearly.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.



18650_ultrafire.jpg

UltraFire 3000mAh, Protected (red label, button-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 02:24, and 03:54 to 50%.
Output then drops in a gradual convex curve.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.



18650_wolfeyes.jpg

Wolf Eyes 2200mAh, Protected (flat-top "+" contact)
Regulation is maintained until 02:11, and 02:38 to 50%.
Output then drops in a convex curve, followed by a steeper linear drop.
Over-discharge protection circuit doesn't seem to trigger.

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Tue May 19, 2009 8:27 pm
by gearhounds
"Incidentally, EagleTac rates the T100C2 at 2 hours Hi mode on the packaging. Assuming this rating was with EagleTac batteries as well, it's been underrated quite a bit as the tests show it getting just shy of 3 hours"

The box specs are for the CR123; the light is spec'd for 3 hours on the Eagletac 18650 at PTS in the description Eagletac is spot on with the lights capabilities with their battery.

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Tue May 19, 2009 10:29 pm
by Mev
Cool thanks for the headsup, I'll edit that redundant bit out :)

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Wed May 20, 2009 2:18 pm
by Mev
Updated with Pila and Wolf Eyes cells.

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Wed May 20, 2009 3:40 pm
by FASTCAR
Seems my mini 18650 shootout months ago was dead on dancenana

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Fri May 22, 2009 10:30 am
by Skier88
Thanks for the shootout - it's been needed for a while. I wonder, how would Trustfires perform? (I believe they are different than Ultrafires)

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Fri May 22, 2009 2:21 pm
by Mev
Are you refering to these TrustFire's?
http://www.dealextreme.com/details.dx/sku.20392

If so, I could purchase them to test out.

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Fri May 22, 2009 6:39 pm
by phantom
I'd like to see those too. According to 'Lermite' tests they have really decent capacity.

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Fri May 22, 2009 7:16 pm
by jirik_cz
From my experience Trustfire 2400/2500, Solarforce 2400, EagleTac 2400 and even some Ultrafire 2400 have decent capacity. And all perform quite similar. But up to 10% difference between two pieces of the same brand is not uncommon. Also loss of 10-30% capacity after 6-12 months of usage is unfortunately quite common.

Hope that coming AW 18650 2600mAh will perform better than current 2200mAh :)

Re: Li-Ion 18650 shootout

PostPosted: Fri May 22, 2009 8:43 pm
by Mev
Alright, I've just purchased those TrustFires.
Will update the graph when I get them.